TOP GUNS: Gundam 0083 Stardust Memory meets Macross Plus as Anime that Have the Most Love for Mecha

There isn’t enough focus on actual mecha in mecha anime. Strange? Yes. Despite the propensity of these shows to act as advertisements for their respective merchendise, I find a lack of actual detailed focus. In recent shows like Macross Frontier and Gundam 00, there are exciting battles and daring maneuvers involving the respective Variable Fighters and Mobile Suits. However, these to me actually serve the narrative more rather than the other way around. As they should, perhaps.

What I’m asking, is whether the mecha in a series be an ensemble dark horse? Do fans of mecha have separate relationships with the mecha and their pilots and related characters? I’m tempted to say yes, as I like certain mechain a show even if I don’t like the show itself as much (i.e. the MSN-04 Sazabi from Char’s Counterattack). That said, I’m quite capable of enjoying a mecha anime show while remaining indifferent or even negative about the mecha (Xam’d, Code Geass).

The mecha, (at least those of the real robot variety) aren’t characters in the show (even if they are sometimes humanized by their pilots, i.e. Ogata Rin and her RideBack Fuego).  If this is so, perhaps at my most charitable I could say that if the elements or factors that make the show enjoyable are analogous to an ensemble cast, then the mecha or one of the mecha would be such a dark horse. This only means one can be a fan of the mecha without having to like the other factors (characters included), or even the show as a whole.

macross-plus-isamu-yf-19-love

"Girl, I've waited for you so long." - Isamu Alva Dyson

Are there anime where there is tremendous love for the mecha without compromising the narrative? Love in the sense that’s played out in the development of prototypes, the conduct of field tests, implied and overt devotion from characters, of course live combat… these are the things make real robot anime exhilerating for me. I have two examples, from both of the big real robot franchises: Gundam 0083 Stardust Memory, and Macross Plus.

Until Macross 7 broke me, Macross Plus was my favorite sequel in the franchise, and my re-watch of Stardust Memory resulted in my elevating it to the top of my Gundam favorites list. I reflected on this and concluded that among the other installments in their respective franchises, here the machines were given more love than in any other. In Macross I can be very sure about this, but I am less confident about Gundam as I’ve still  yet to see a number of  shows in its metaverse (though I’ve found no evidence in my readings to contradict my impression).

At this point I will speculate on a few things. Shoji Kawamori, Macross’ original creator and mechanical designer spent his student years as a Gundam fan. Some trivia: In episode 2 of the original SDF Macross, after dealing with the first wave of fighter pods, Major Focker radios “Skull Leader to Gunsight One.” Gunsight, besides being the tactical call-sign for the bridge of the SDF-1 Macross, also was the fanzine title of the Gundam fan club that creator Kawamori Shoji, character designer Mikimoto Haruhiko, and writer Oonogi Hiroshi (Members #1, #2, and #3) founded while at Keio University. His work on Macross, Do You Remember Love, and Flashback 2012 had Sunrise assign him on 1991′s Gundam 0083: Stardust Memory (as mechanical designer).  Personally I find this story rather heartwarming, as there’s nothing like a fanboy getting to work on his dream project, despite what some industry veterans say. The idea that Stardust Memory has some of the franchise’s best-looking mecha (I definitely concur) only makes this story more satisfying to me.

I daresay that 1994′s Macross Plus took a lot of elements from Stardust Memory, and I’ll lay that on Kawamori himself. In any case, the similarities are all good things to me. Here’s the list:

  • Prototype mecha
  • Field tests
  • Adult characters
  • Regret as a theme (unfinished business)
  • Love triangle (albeit a Macross staple, and Macross Plus did it much, much better; or perhaps Stardust Memory really just did a slipshod job)
  • Glorious duels (both shows to me, are the best showcases from each franchise)

I’ll look into the above elements in detail, and add a few more: how each show contributes to their respective continuities, and franchises as a whole.

Prototype Mecha

Stardust Memory introduced a good number, all of them winners:

rx-781-gp01-gundam-zephyrantes

RX-78GP01 Gundam “Zephyranthes”

rx-781-gp01-gundam-full-vernian-zephyrantes

RX-78GP01-Fb Gundam Full Vernian “Zephyranthes”

rx-781-gp02-gundam-physalis

RX-78GP02A Gundam “Physalis”

rx-781-gp03-dendrobium-orchis

RX-78GP03 Gundam “Dendrobium Orchis”

rx-781-gp03s-dendrobium-stamen

RX-78GP03S Gundam “Dendrobium Stamen”

amx-002-neue-ziel

AMX-002 (AMA-X2) Neue Ziel

All but the Neue Ziel are Earth Federation Gundams. The links lead to Mecha Anime Headquarter’s detailed profiles. These prototypes are very bad boys. No doubt that they are powerful relative to the average mobile suit, but what I like about the pace of the arms race that created them is that the resulting abilities aren’t too fantastic or over-the-top (relatively speaking of course!). The technology and application are ‘grounded in real robot reality.’ The Gundam franchise will go on and make ‘overpowered’ prototypes in Wing, SEED Destiny, and now 00. While there’s nothing wrong with such paths, my taste favors the ‘technological aesthetics’ of Stardust Memory.

To give a picture, beam weapons borne by the prototypes are as powerful as those mounted on capital ships – making these ships very vulnerable and the prototypes very dangerous. What would make them overpowered in my view, is when the mecha themselves become impervious to such beam weapons.

The most advanced prototypes eventually did, through force-field like implements. However, never did it seem like a prototype can just ‘stand’ in one place and take continuous fire with only the force field/energy barrier protecting it. Along with the energy barrier’s weakness against kinetic projectiles, the resulting duels and battles never felt like static barrages but rather feverish scraps and passes. More on this later.

gn005-virtue

One of my pet favorite Gundams, Gundam 00's GN005 "Virtue" a.k.a. "Fatass" Gundam

For comparison’s sake, let’s look at Gundam 00′s GN005 Virtue. Size wise it’s smaller than the Dendrobium Orchis and the Neue Ziel, but it’s nowhere as quick and maneuverable. Mind you I am very fond of the Gundam Virtue. It’s so slow relative to its enemies (even those who aren’t in its class) that it has no choice but to rely on its energy barrier to protect itself. It compensates for this lack of speed and maneuverability by having a beam weapon that’s relatively (non-technical analysis wise) much stronger than any of those in Stardust Memory, even if only to look at the width of the beam fired. The Virtue’s particle cannon can destroy an entire unit of mobile suits. This makes watching it fight boring after a while.

The revelation of the technology upgrades in Stardust Memory is very fast, given the length of the OAV (13 episodes). But even so, it never felt like there were gigantic leaps. And yet, the prototypes were indeed decisive weapons in the field (the Neue Ziel in particular had a stupendous kill count). I can’t help but find this a triumph for the show.

yf-19

YF-19

yf-21

YF-21

In the case of Macross Plus, you get a powerful sense of how wonderful it is to be flying one of these machines. In SDF Macross you had Hikaru Ichijyo who was a flight nut. He was obsessed with flying and his personality was crippled without his being able to fly. Macross Plus continues this tradition by making the show revolve entirely on the piloting aspect of its characters. It had the impetuous Isamu Dyson who visualized his flight behavior with his body. From his youth, his entire personality is about flying and when he is flying – the kind that is distinguished from fighting, you are taken for a ride into his character, connected to the joy of wind carrying him high above the clouds.

macross-plus-isamu-flight-visualization-2macross-plus-isamu-flight-visualization-1macross-plus-isamu-flight-visualizationmacross-plus-in-his-mind-hes-already-flying

Did I playact this to myself over the last 15 years? You bet.

When they’re in their machines, nothing feels for granted. The show makes a big deal with how the mecha is controlled. Not in terms of realism, but rather thought and effort went into portraying the nature of flying the mecha. In Stardust Memory you had the pilots give feedback as to how different the performance of the prototypes are in terms of output and handling, in Macross Plus you had the YF-21 prototype run with a different primary control system: one that is directly connected to the brain.

Yes, Guld's piloting the YF-21 in the middle of a dogfight with his eyes closed.

Yes, Guld's piloting the YF-21 in the middle of a dogfight with his eyes closed.

Ironically, this system is a conceit made by the Robotech novels – when they described how the mecha were controlled using ‘thinking caps.’

In both anime, a good deal of attention and detail is devoted to the mecha themselves though never to the distraction of the main narrative.  Rather, they set up the narratives: Stardust Memory had a Gundam prototype with a nuclear warhead that was the objective of the remnants of the Principality of Zeon. Macross Plus had two rival prototypes vying for the singular military contract, piloted respectively by former friends and current rivals. The resulting stories are bigger than these premises.

Field Tests

Given that the mecha herein are prototypes, it makes absolute sense that a large amount of effort is put in to test and ensure their performance. In mecha anime such as Zeta Gundam, Gundam 00, and Code Geass, lots and lots of new prototype or one-of-a-kind mecha are introduced almost every other episode.  However, very little attention is dedicated to the development of these weapons.  Macross never made a tradition of narrating prototype development (though one gets a sense of such in Macross 0) as there aren’t that many new mecha that debut in the middle of the show, but Macross 7 rolled out a lot of new models without getting into their development.

I’m not saying that the lack of attention to weapon development is a weakness of a show. It’s just that I do personally find them very interesting, and I credit both Stardust Memory and Macross Plus for showcasing the development aspects, the work behind the scenes that goes into making these beatiful and terrible war machines.

gundam-0083-gpo1-full-vernian-field-test-1gundam-0083-gpo1-full-vernian-field-test-2gundam-0083-gpo1-full-vernian-field-test-3gundam-0083-gpo1-full-vernian-field-test-4

Field Trials on the moon, hot female development team, lots of pseudo-scientific technical jargon, 18-meter tall giant robot, WHAT’S NOT TO LIKE?

The space-outfitted GP01 is taken through its paces by Nina Purpleton and her team, and pilot Kou Uraki. I find it very interesting that when Kou did not use specific adjustments to allow for the vacuum of space, the Zephyrantes performed quite poorly, which resulted in significant combat damage. I really, really liked this touch. What does it really accomplish? It adds a layer of atmosphere, of setting. It’s as if it were a slice of the lives of these people in the context of a technological arms race.  Furthermore, it gets us accustomed to Kou doing well as a pilot – such when he actually produces very good results in battle, it’s not completely far-fetched. In the case of Macross Plus where the test pilots are already servicemen of some repute, the field tests provide the necessary view for us to see how good they are.

macross-plus-test-trials-1macross-plus-test-trials-2-test-centralmacross-plus-test-trials-3-test-central-data-miningmacross-plus-test-trials-4-city-exercise-field

What’s better than a Field Test? A Field Test involving TWO sexy Variable Fighters, THAT’S WHAT!

Furthermore, and for better or worse, the personal rivalry of the test pilots play out in their antics in the Field Tests. The conflict in Macross Plus is a personal one, as the whole narrative plays out in peace time.  The resulting hijinks (as these conflicts would appear if the slices of their lives were played out in a school setting and not in a aeronautical test course) become a visual feast that showcases the mecha and the talent of the pilots.

Test trials are given much importance in Macross Plus given that these prototypes are competing with each other for the exclusive military contract. Macross just made an interesting military anime while in a setting that is entirely in peace time. Watching these trials is a thrill because the machines are really showcased well, and benefit from spectacular action choreography (Itano Ichiro). These trials are arguably more exciting than many other dogfights in duels in mecha anime.

Adult Characters, Love Triangles, and Regret as a Theme

While SDF Macross‘ primary characters are of high school age, the Macross Plus triangle averages at 24 years old (with all three within a year of each other in age). Still much younger than I am but at that age a person is fully capable of regret.

macross-plus-guld-myung-isamu-triangle

Stardust Memories‘ triangle (ugh) averages a little over 21 years old, but has larger gaps (Kou is 19, Nina is 21, and Anavel is 25). The older characters have lived long enough to have a history with each other, leaving Kou as the wet-behind-the-ears rookie.

What is the significance of this? The temptation is to think that these characters will be less emotional. This is a trap. Characters who are subject to external stress can get emotional. However, older characters are less prone to whine. While there is indeed less whining apparent in these shows, this is also due to the scenes that don’t linger on the tears, the brooding and anger.

While crying out or shouting, weeping or wailing are inevitable human expressions of emotions, it doesn’t mean that these are entertaining. The narrative pace of both series being short allows for the abbreviation of scenes where I expect a character to be indulged his angst-ridden emoting. But equally important is how they are given wonderful toys to work out their emotions through. I mean, I wouldn’t cry so badly if I had a Variable Fighter, or a Freaking Gundam to pilot.

Kou Uraki is not the flight-obsessed character that Isamu is, and his orientation is really towards combat as there is an ongoing conflict. Factor in his youth he is the most emotionally um, vocal among the pilots in these shows. Nonetheless, he manned up quite well – and easily is the only character that had genuine growth (as opposed to resolution) that plays out in the narrative: from s0mewhat whiny old kid to MAN OF DESTINY.

Anavel Gato, a character who is already a legend at the onset of the narrative, behaved consistently ruthless yet honorable, and entirely dedicated to his ideals. I seriously enjoyed almost every scene he’s in.

Nina Purpleton doesn’t fit the normal conventions of leading ladies in mecha anime, in terms of character design. I really think she’s played well enough, though her distress and tears escalated and more plentiful as the series progressed. In the final episode however, I almost thought she’d ruin the whole show for me.

Between the three, Anavel and Nina carry regret. Anavel Gato wished to die during the last stand of Zeon in the One Year War, he’s here because he has unfinished business with the federation. Nina’s regret has something to do with Anavel.

In Macross Plus, the anguish and tears are borne mostly by Myung Fang-Lone the successful ‘producer’ of the superstar idol Sharon Apple. I’m not going to give anything further away, only that the three leading characters (Isamu Alva Dyson, Guld Goa Bowman) all have unfinished business with each other, and it affects their work in powerful ways, perhaps Myung most of all. They were all friends from their youths, with Myung apparently favoring Isamu over Guld, who played the dedicated friend. He didn’t get in their way, until some violence that occurred that estranged all of them from each other.

Perhaps it’s also important to note that both shows, but particularly and awesomely Stardust Memory, have  mature side characters. You’ll meet the likes of South Burning, Eiphar Synapse, and Cima Garahau; and all of them are badass, despite their sillly names that the Gundam franchise is so full with.

Glorious Duels and Battles

Stardust Memory has both very good and great duels, mostly between the prototypes and the rival pilots. The technology between the prototypes is quite even so no one really enjoyed an unfair advantage. The duels played out on the ground, in the air, and in space. I never felt wanting for more, and was quite satisfied. In classic Gundam fashion, the characters shout at each other a lot about ideology and perhaps philosophy during the battles – as the pilots make attacking passes at each other (Macross does this too, particularly in Macross Frontier). This isn’t as corny or distracting as it sounds. Rather, one feels that the pilots are powered by their beliefs, and they punctuate their arguments by their attacks. Good stuff.

gundam-0083-gato-kou-split-screen

MEN OF DESITINY

But where Stardust Memory truly shines, is in its big set-piece battles. Operation Stardust itself, the code name of this massive undertaking of the remnants of the Zeon forces,  is sheer pleasure to watch unfold. I felt that the show paced it brilliantly, and when the big weapons came into play, the dramatic effect was very good.

It also featured some really good combined arms warfare: from submarines to capital ships to asteroid bases fighting with and against mobile suits. The fleet sizes don’t amount to those in say, Legend of the Galactic Heroes, but each casualty, for whatever reason I felt that it counted. It never felt that each side had inexhaustible ‘mooks‘ or ‘red shirts.’ What this makes me feel is that each mobile suit is important. Each piece of mecha and each pilot are valuable and limited resources. Gundam really does well with this. In the Macross franchise I can’t help but feel that there are way too many ‘cheap kills’, particularly in SDF-Macross and annoyingly in Macross 7.

gundam-0083-neue-ziel-with-zaku-killed

Also, battle damage. The prototypes never feel immortal. It makes the feats accomplished through them so much more satisfying. In a heated fight, whether a duel from a skirmish or an out-and-out battle, armor and shields get punctured, mechanical limbs get lost, weapons get destroyed, ammunition needs replenishing, pilots get injured or killed, and so on.  It’s quite good to note that in contemporary sequels such as Gundam 00 and Macross Frontier, these things happen as well if perhaps not at the regularity or grittiness found in Stardust Memory.

Furthermore, and perhaps my favorite aspect of the anime (mecha aside) are the sustained battles. Here we have battles that take a long time, where pilots get very exhausted. Two images come to mind: a pilot falling asleep in his cockpit in while his mobile suit was being serviced between sorties, and Kou rolling up his sleeves and injecting himself with some kind of drug which I assume keeps him in fighting form.

gundam-0083-kou-shooting-up

Fatigue is palpable. Sweat, heavy breathing, tired talk… what a rush.

Macross Plus doesn’t have grand set piece battles, but it does have the most spectacular dogfights in anime. They’re really that good. You get a taste of such during the the Test Trials, but when it got really serious the choreography, the animation quality deliver really strong stuff.

macross-plus-isamu-vs-guld-the-beauty-of-dogfightmacross-plus-isamu-vs-guld-the-beauty-of-dogfight-2

In the end, one particular capital ship is involved, and it’s really special. I purposely did not provide video clips for this section because they’ll just spoil the experience. If you can get the remastered editions of these shows, go ahead and do so.

Music

Stardust Memory has my favorite OPs in the franchise, though its BGM is unremarkable – after two viewings I can’t recall a single melody. The 2nd OP is just so badass.

Men of Destiny

Macross Plus has no proper OP nor ED, though it enjoys a ridiculous advantage: it’s the anime OST debut of one Kanno Yoko. The very start of the first episode, as well as the closing credits of the finale, is accompained by Voices, one of the first songs in an anime that I really truly loved. The first three episodes is scored by a  track that hardly any Kanno fan talks about: Torch Song/After, in the dark. The video below also includes some exciting footage from different parts of the OVA.

Contributions to the Franchise and the Meta-Narrative

I’ve spoken about the mecha being the premise in both shows, but they aren’t the core conflict. The heart of the narratives are in other things, things that are substantial to a fan of fiction in general. In Stardust Memory we have a story of nations, the side story is a very interesting origin piece that sets up the geopolitics in a larger story (Zeta Gundam). It does this very well, in my opinion. The contributions of the players may be obscured by history (as seems necessary since this is a prequel made nearly a decade after its ‘successor’), but their struggles within the narrative are quite notable.

The elements that characterize the franchise are given much focus and are presented impressively: the mecha and the technological arms race, the use of WMD (including a colony drop), large-scale and sustained fleet battles, the wear of war on those who take part in it, rival ace pilots, the evil inherent in the machinery of war organization (politics), and even ideology. One thing remarkably absent is the concept of Newtypes – part of the evolution of the human race that is quite central in the Universal Century’s list of themes. I’m not a fan of it at all, and I acknowledge this absence contributes to the enjoyment I have of Stardust Memory.

Technologically, the presence of an energy barrier particularly in the Neue Ziel presents a problem in the continuity. While records of the Gundam prototypes did disappear, those of the Neue Ziel have no reason to. The problem here is that these prototypes have the I-field – an energy barrier effective against beam weapons. This technology is wholly absent in Zeta Gundam, the next show in the continuity. There is no reason for the manufacturers of the Neue Ziel to not have the capacity to produce this technology for the contemporary mobile suits circa Zeta Gundam.

Stardust Memory takes most of the elements of the Gundam franchise and showcases them in a very impressive way. This is why I think this show is important, despite it not necessarily being the pinnacle of the Gundam metaverse.

Macross Plus’ core conflict is that of people.  It’s a more character driven work. The initial premise that parallels the human rivalry with that of the prototype mecha is made moot by the emergeance of a third prototype, an unmanned fighter – the Ghost X-9. The external conflict then becomes a human vs. machine one. The rivalry, once resolved (quite triumphantly) frees the characters to fight agains the artificial intellegence antagonist (It is said that Shoji Kawamori is an admirer of Stanley Kubrick’s 2001 Space Oddysey and the names Bowman and Dyson are some of the shoutouts to that film).

The emergeance of the A.I. Idol

The emergeance of the A.I. Idol (yes, the box is the idol)

Like Stardust Memory, Macross Plus showcases many of the distinguishing features of the Macross franchise: the love triangle, idol singers, ace pilots, dogfights (as opposed to Gundam’s duels), battles scored and edited to seem like music videos, and of course the transformable mecha. There are a number of things that this show did differently. In this instance, music wasn’t a positive force. It was very much a part of the problem. Also, there was no alien race or culture to tame, it really was more an exposition on how the great space war resulted in the initiation of galactic colonization.

It’s contributions to the greater narrative however, are minimal. This is the case of the sequels in Macross anyway. Unlike Gundam, which creates ‘new’ stories that are situated within a larger narrative that  has already been resolved for all intents and purposes (the Universal Century), Macross comes up with deliberate sequels – expansions of the narrative, for better or worse.  The constraints of the Universal Century narrative rein in the elements which provides specific boundaries to fantasy and results in very consistent shows.  Except for the prequel Macross 0, all of Macross is new, which results in very alien elements (wherein the only consistent thing is that the aliens are alien, and are affected by music in some way). I personally think Macross side stories will be interesting though, but I sense an aversion from the creators to re-visit past material beyond re-telling it through new characters, and through homage.

Sharon Apple live, in concert

Sharon Apple live, in concert

Can one have a fulfilling experience of the Macross franchise without watching Macross Plus? Yes. Despite the linear narrative, Macross Plus contributes very little to the overall thread, as do most of the sequels. It’s contributions internally and externally are technological: A. I., mecha (internally), achievements in animation and specifically CG (externally).

Nonetheless, I do think both shows can stand on their own merits. The production values are very high, and the narrativs move along at a brisk pace, aided by the conciseness of both series (13 episodes for Stardust Memory, 4 episodes for Macross Plus).  But if you like mecha anime, and like real robots these two OVAs are a real treat, they really let the machines shine very very bright.

Haven’t seen any Gundam at all? Don’t know where to start? Find your Gateway Gundam!

About ghostlightning

I entered the anime blogging sphere as a lurker around Spring 2008. We Remember Love is my first anime blog. Click here if this is your first time to visit WRL.
This entry was posted in analysis, comparative, fanboy, Gundam, Macross and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

47 Responses to TOP GUNS: Gundam 0083 Stardust Memory meets Macross Plus as Anime that Have the Most Love for Mecha

  1. Takuya-kun says:

    you forgot to mention eva

    though it wasnt much of “i love eva” show, all the detailed technical elements are much there, they take like 2 minutes just to start up an eva

  2. schneider says:

    Damn, what really long post. I’ll be commenting in trickles, if you don’t mind.

    Another piece of tech that shouldn’t have existed in Stardust Memory is Neue Ziel’s wire-guided beam arms. They’re supposed to be Newtype-controlled, but 0083 cheats by saying a computer does half of the work for it. Which would still be an impressive feat to accomplish, in terms of tech and piloting.

    It’s quite amusing to note that a lot of evidence points to Gato not having participated in the Battle of Solomon at all. I enjoyed his character but can’t help but feel he’s overrated. :P

    The lack of Gerbera Tetra in this post makes me sad. Hell, it’s a Gundam frame given the Zeon look, and has a beam machine gun to boot!

  3. ghostlightning says:

    @ Takuya-kun

    Eva is indeed notable, and a lot of attention has been paid to the technical (and mythological) aspects of the Eva units, however I do feel that the focus was on these units are different from how these two shows.

    It does merit its own discussion though, so thank you for pointing it out.

    @ schneider

    I don’t mind.

    The Gerbara Tetra does feel like a serious omission, however there wasn’t enough of it in the anime I felt. Also, I didn’t mind the wire-guided arms, though it does seem remarkable that no new mecha have been produced to assist non-newtypes.

    However, given that the Newtypes are the future of humanity, it doesn’t make sense to put devote further capacity to implement such tools.

    It would probably be like developing games for the Playstation 2 in their minds, knowing that the Playstation 3 is already ‘current’ tech, and still has much unexplored possibilities.

    That said, given the time between 0083 and Char’s Counterattack (0093), there should be at least a few models that should’ve used such features. After all, the Azieru DIDN’T have a pilot until Quess Paraya conveniently showed up.

    Regarding Gato, the retcon job is perhaps not very well done. Someone of his stature should’ve figured somehow in First Gundam. I don’t mind this, and take what’s available in 0083 as canon anyway. Why is he overrated? If the claim is that he’s the best non-NT pilot, then who is? Is he better than some NT’s? I’m inclined to think so.

    Show me your rankings!

    • schneider says:

      The OYW was a huge battlefield. The story of the RX-78-2 Gundam wasn’t even a big part of it–Amuro and Char weren’t even the top aces of their respective sides. Some of the top aces were even Oldtypes.

      As far as Newtype OYW aces go, Johnny Ridden was one of the best. He fought in A Baoa Qu and lived through it. Cool guy overall, and loyal to the very end (he was Kycilla’s sort of personal knight).

      I would have to rank Kou near the top, for sheer potential and endurance. Gato is great, but he only showed the real extent of his piloting abilities in the Neue Ziel (most of the GP01-GP02 skirmishes were disappointing for me). Yazan the Violator is also very good. Gaiden-wise, Yuu Kajima is amazing for living throughout the years and joining Londo Bell during the Axis incident. There’s also Master Pierce Rayer of White Dingo. I think Kayra isn’t bad, too–her only glaring flaw was not being a Newtype in the first place.

      However the list of notable pilots in the UC is too big, and ranking them would cause too much of a shitstorm. I can’t even decide for myself between Amuro and Kamille as the better pilot.

      • ghostlightning says:

        The OYW was a huge battlefield. The story of the RX-78-2 Gundam wasn’t even a big part of it–Amuro and Char weren’t even the top aces of their respective sides. Some of the top aces were even Oldtypes.

        I concur.

        Gato is great, but he only showed the real extent of his piloting abilities in the Neue Ziel (most of the GP01-GP02 skirmishes were disappointing for me).

        I had thought about this a great deal. I had always taken his not destroying the Zephyrantes and Kou during the initial Gundamjack against him. Why was he more interested in lecturing a n00b than destroying a potential rival or at least a Gundam?

        This is what I think: Kou had to grow into becoming an ace, and of course his untimely death at the hands of Gato wouldn’t result in much of a story. That doesn’t necessarily excuse the implausibility I mentioned (in addition to the fact that given Gato’s abilities, he could have easily taken out the entire Albion IMO), however I do forgive it.

        Stardust Memory saved Gato’s best for last. I would have to re-visit the shows where a number of pilots you mentioned are in though. In any case I’m due to watch Zeta TV soon.

  4. Turambar says:

    While watching Robotech Macross back in China as a wee lad secured my love for Valkyries in general, (It’s the only thing I remember from the show honestly), just the random youtube clips I’ve seen of Macross Plus made the YF-19 my favorite Valkyrie in the entire franchise, and probably favorite real robot period. Its thin sleek design, forward swept wings, and a clean white color scheme just screams awesome.

  5. Turambar says:

    “It would probably be like developing games for the Playstation 2 in their minds, knowing that the Playstation 3 is already ‘current’ tech, and still has much unexplored possibilities.”

    The PS2 will live on as long as Atlus is around to pump out awesome games for it. =)

    • ghostlightning says:

      The YF-19 is probably the sleekest Valkyrie (V mode) ever, however I don’t think it has the best Battloid form at all. It’s a bit clunky, despite its somewhat rounded silhouette – compared to the old VF1s.

      Furthermore, it’s far from VF1 white. It has this weird cream/yellow color.

      The sleeker Battloid is the YF-21. Look at those legs! It’s not for everyone, but I find it strangely beautiful in an alien way.

      As for the PS2 and Altus, the reference I made in relation to the Universal Century Gundam continuity will mean this:

      Anaheim Electronics will be more like Electronic Arts or Square Enix. It doesn’t make sense for them to invest in obsolete technology – this is the premise. However as I said in my response to schneider, it still is fishy to have produced for still relevant platforms for an entire decade.

      • Turambar says:

        I’ve never been all to particular about the battloid forms of Valkyries when it comes to their aesthetic feel. They’ve more or less have cemented in my mind as fighter jets with arms and legs. Though it is a somewhat flawed mental image I will admit.

        The YF-21 battloid form actually feels off balance to me. It’s wings don’t seem to fold away unlike most Valkyries and it ends up wearing the fuselage on it’s back. Further, it’s legs aren’t composed of the thrusters which remain unfolded. It’s rather top heavy form makes me wonder how it’s legs can handle the weight. On the other hand, it’s head is probably the best looking out of all other Valkyries to me with it’s red circular eye. The rectangular camera of most of them just don’t quite jive with me.

        Of course, I do have the personal bias of finding the actual F-14 that most Valkyries are based off of as pretty bulky and kind of ugly as well, so….

    • ghostlightning says:

      The red circular eye is straight out of Gundam’s Zaku design.

      If you ask me what is the best or at least what my favorite VF model is, it’s Macross Frontier’s VF-25 Messiah. Everything about it is sleek and sexy. I built a model kit of it so I appreciate the design even more.

      It does owe it’s base frame design to the YF-19, where the rear of the cockpit becomes its center torso piece, though it’s far less bulky.

      I do think that the battloid heads were never remarkable, though the VF-1S “Skull One” is probably the most distinctive with its 4 guns sticking out like 2 pairs of small horns.

  6. schneider says:

    @ ghostlightning

    Before you start looking for them in animated Gundam media, Yuu Kajima and Master P. Rayer are from obscure Gundam games. Kajima was in Blue Destiny for the Saturn, and piloted experimental mobile suits with the EXAM system (which is like the Zero System but with a soul of a Newtype). Rayer was the protagonist of Rise From the Ashes, a Dreamcast game. He went from a lowly GM to a GM Sniper II with specs rivaling the RX-78, and royally kicked Zeon ass in Australia.

    • ghostlightning says:

      Thanks, but are these characters canon? I wouldn’t be surprised if they are, though I’m kind of uncomfortable about these things happening in different media.

      • It depends who you ask whether they’re canon or not. Some people feel that, given the technological gap, and the perceived failure to properly integrate with Zeta and MSG, even 0083 isn’t canon, and I have some sympathy with that view, though I don’t share it.

        This was an odd read for me: Plus is my favourite part of the Macross franchise, but 0083 is among my least favourite parts of Gundam.

        I think Kawamori’s 0083 design work is brilliant, and I love the action in the first half of the show. But I don’t like Mobile Armours, and especially not something like the Dendrobium Orchis, which takes a perfectly nice Gundam and turns it into an uninteresting weapons box. Gundam Sentinel did massive-long-range-space-warfare-machines much better, I feel. And I’d argue that the reason the mecha are great without compromising the narrative is because the narrative is already massively compromised. But I know you like 0083, and I can understand why – I don’t want to give the impression that I have a problem with people liking or loving it. It’s eminently loveable.

        Plus, meanwhile, is just brilliant.

      • schneider says:

        The rule of thumb is, once characters/MS appear in video games, they’re canon. Especially the SD Gundam G-Generation series (in which both of them do appear), which is like the ultimate dream matchup game for Gundam fans.

        I also got to play as the White Dingo custom MS in my PSP game. The Blue Destiny units also have their own HGUCs.

  7. @ The Animanachronism

    Oh boy. This is where I throw up my hands and just laugh at the diversity of people’s tastes in general.

    I sympathize with the view that the narrative of 0083 is compromized (I believe I mentioned how the love triangle business nearly ruined it for me despite how fond I was of the show), I’ve forgiven much of it due to the elements I’ve mentioned above.

    Also, I really really like mobile armors. I love their monstrous bulk and proportions, and what they meant for the Zeonic hopes. Remember, ONCE THE BIG ZAM IS MASS PRODUCED… Bless their technological silver bullet loving hearts.

    And then re Plus we actually have so few things to discuss. Ah well, Plus is love.

    • Indeed, indeed. de gustibus non est disputandum, as I think we’re meant to say at times like these. I like the Big Zam (relevant: http://tinyurl.com/cs7zje ), because its design is monstrous, rather than just boxy or bulbous. It looks like giant monster out of a fairy tale – perfect for the humanoid Gundam/knight to destroy.

      • ghostlightning says:

        Thank you very much for that image! I must use that for a post some time! I’d love to write more about the significance of technological silver bullets to Zeon and its representation as mobile armors (after the initial success of the mobile suit) but I think I would have to watch ZZ and V in order to provide a comprehensive view.

        I’d appreciate any advice you have on the matter.

  8. Well, to save time you could restrict yourself to the Zeon. Adding the Zanscare would complicate things, because there isn’t the continuity that runs through from MSG to CCA. That said, V is unusual because there are several prototypes for the title Victory Gundam which get used together, rather than just having one prototype as is the norm.

    Personally, it sounds like an interesting post idea, but I don’t know much about the nitty-gritty of technological development philosophies.

    • ghostlightning says:

      Thanks man, I’ll definitely take it on. I don’t really know myself of nittiness and grit of technological development philosophies, but I wager it’ll be a fun exploration.

      • schneider says:

        Don’t forget that wasting too much time and resources on the Big Zam cost Zeon the war! But, yeah, attacking a mobile suit with a submachine gun–that was the best.

    • ghostlightning says:

      Yes, schneider that is also why the /m/eme enchants me so. I’m working on this theory on how Zeon’s obsession with super-weapons; whether they be cannons, the Zaku, and ridiculous mobile armors.

      Re-watching MS Igloo 1 and now 1stGundam (movies) brings me to how acute the human resource problem is in the OYW (more a Zeonic problem, I feel).

      Having less ready pilots, makes the design and commitment to singular units capable of leveling the battlefield by themselves make more sense. As Zeon cannot hope to compete with the Feddie GM rush tactics.

      The size of the armors, however is an aesthetic conceit that makes for little practical value in my view. The whole desperation and inevitability of their demise in the OYW up until Operation Stardust makes for such charming and compelling stories to me.

  9. Crusader says:

    I didn’t think that 0083 integrated all that seamlessly, but it did at least give some background on how the Feddies created the Titans. Even if Neue Ziel was more advanced than most of the stuff in Zeta I thought is was cool and badass, if only they still made them like that.

    As an overall contribution to the UC timeline it did show that the creation of the Titans was not totally unjustified and that Zeon might have had pretensions to honor but in the notable case of Cima she was thrown under the bus by guys like Delaz and Gato who felt that any sort of killing to further their goals was justified for Zabi Hegemony, more specifically Gihren’s school of Zeon. In that sense I don’t think of Gato as honorable just deluded, after all what honor is there in starting a war just so that Gato could die to satisfy his own ego and ease his survivors guilt? Just like a the knights of old honor only applied to certain people in certain cases, as for those Feddies they were only peasants to him, and like the old blue bloods killing them was no problem at all…

    In the case of Macross Plus it was enjoyable overall and had some very sexy dog fights. Even if the YF-19 did not become standard it was still cool, and I am sure that Grace might have learned a thing or too about code from Sharon Apple, not to mention Sheryl seemed to embrace the use of holograms…not a total loss in my book.

    • ghostlightning says:

      In that sense I don’t think of Gato as honorable just deluded, after all what honor is there in starting a war just so that Gato could die to satisfy his own ego and ease his survivors guilt? Just like a the knights of old honor only applied to certain people in certain cases, as for those Feddies they were only peasants to him, and like the old blue bloods killing them was no problem at all…

      Great! This lets me talk about ‘good’ characters distinguished from their moral or ethical soundness (I hesitate to say ‘well written’). My fondness for Gato (or Zeon for that matter) has little to do with them being right. It maybe politically or morally repugnant to like them, but I do nonetheless even if only for the reason that they interest me.

      As for the Titans, I think the premise of their creation isn’t problematic – it’s the eventual operation of the unit that is. The best ‘in anime’ discussions about this phenomenon are within Legend of the Galactic Heroes.

      and I am sure that Grace might have learned a thing or too about code from Sharon Apple, not to mention Sheryl seemed to embrace the use of holograms…

      THIS. I think credit goes to Macross Frontier for taking these things further than Macross 7 did. One thing that did bother me is how the Ghost-class fighters got ‘nerfed’ in Macross Frontier. It’s hinted that there’s some AI inhibitor applied to them to explain how they became such Vajra fodder (see Luca’s Judah System), how little their impact was in the finale. It’s not like there was an abundance of Guld Bowman level pilots in the NUNS fleet in that battle. I just thought the number of Ghosts in that battle would be a very decisive advantage for the Galaxy fleet.

      What do you make of this?

  10. cuchlann says:

    Hey hey. How about we keep the posts that make me want to mainline stuff until *after* I finish my thesis, huh? : D

    • ghostlightning says:

      I actually have a strategy towards the most efficient Gundam franchise consumption that has the least impact on a person’s current watch list, or thesis writing in your case. Recommending it to yet-to-be-fans of the franchise have honed my skills to a fine edge. In the meantime, you can try this little guide we prepared:

      Find your Gateway Gundam!

      Buzz me on Gtalk!

  11. gloval says:

    Whoa, long entry is long, but it’s quite comprehensive.

    (Just that I can’t participate in the Gundam half of the discussion, sad. Actually, reading the comments, most of the discussion is about Gundam, even sadder.)

    Anyway, since you mentioned how music isn’t a positive force in Macross Plus, I would mention again that it’s precisely why when Sharon Apple used music to deceive and control, she met her downfall. That is, in the Macross universe, music should not be used negatively.

    Although the Ghost may have been sort of reconciled back with the good guys, as culminated in the final battle of Macross Frontier when Luca activated the Judah AI for his Ghosts, the cautionary theme against high technology is still present since Frontier now have cyborgs to contend with.

    Also, didn’t knew about the Space Odyssey connection! The AI antagonist should’ve given me a clue, but I totally failed to see the similarity in character names!

    By the way, now that my blog has its first Macross entry, my name now links to it. It’s not actually an anime blog, but more of a hobby/geek blog.

    • ghostlightning says:

      Gundam inspires intense fan behavior that’s quite different from how Macross does it. I find Gundam interesting and fascinating, while I find Macross supremely lovable.

      I notice that after the original series, the moral stand – especially on music (and then ecology) has become heavier handed. And yet, Macross remains as lighthearted and fun as it always has been. I think this a good thing and an achievement of the franchise.

      I’m still not satisfied with how the Ghosts behaved throughout Macross Frontier though.

  12. Pingback: 100th Post: The Super Dimensional Journey of Love Remembered « We Remember Love

  13. vendredi says:

    Rather late to comment on this one, but very interesting points throughout. I think actually it might be a start on a typology of “real-robot” anime – all those elements you mention are the sorts of things I think people consider when they try to think of what makes a “real-robot” anime different from a “super robot” anime – it’s the attention to the small mechanical details, past history, even things as small as having start-up sequences.

    It’s very interesting how you note a dichotomy between Gundam and Macross, and how each fandom have their own differences (perhaps material for a follow-up post?)

    In my own case these sorts of differences are pretty evident, my introduction to mecha was mostly through Gundam (starting with Wing back in the 90s), with very little Macross experience.
    On the other hand, I have a friend who got into mecha via the Robotech/Macross route, with little exposure to Gundam, so it’s interesting to see how our expectations out of mecha anime differ.

    • ghostlightning says:

      Oh man, yours is the kind of comment that really gets me excited!

      Regarding the typology of real vs. super robot anime, it’s actually more complex as it seems. mechafetish and I are always talking about it and we seem to be in a conundrum.

      Regarding the mecha anime route, I got in through the Super Robot shows like Choudenji Machine Voltes V, as did almost everyone in my generation. I got into real robots through Macross, but I wasn’t really aware of the distinction until I really started reading about it on the internet a few years ago.

      This increased my intrigue towards Gundam, and though I was really late to the party, I’m very much a Gundam fanboy.

      The Gundam/Macross ‘dichotomy’ is explored by The Animanachronism here.

      His exposure to Macross is quite limited at the time of his writing though, perhaps comparable to the limitations of my own exposure to Gundam. Nonetheless, I agree with his points.

      In any case, I won’t be able to help myself and these comparisons will indeed come up in future posts. For now, I really find Gundam irresistibly intriguing, while I find Macross supremely lovable.

      Really, thanks for this comment – it makes writing so much more rewarding ^_^

  14. Pingback: Gundam is Much More than the Universal Century, But UC is What I Love « We Remember Love

  15. Pingback: Keeping it Real Robot « We Remember Love

  16. Pingback: Macross Zero is a Peculiar Prequel « We Remember Love

  17. Pingback: The Recency Bias and How it Affects Anime Appreciation « We Remember Love

  18. Pingback: An Overarching Methodology Behind Anime and Manga Appreciation: a Reflection « We Remember Love

  19. Pingback: We Remember Our First Year in Blogging: WRL Turns One Year, Lessons Learned « We Remember Love

  20. Pingback: First Two: Anabelle Gateaux, the Nightmare of Solomon | Baden Baden Lily

  21. Akyli says:

    Those series are good but for a gundam fan and a macross follower I like those concepts. infact not to lie but I think that Macross plus is the best out of the macross series in terms of plot, charcters, mecha/jet action (most detailed) and finally the opening song really caught me. As for Stardust Memory I watched a few eps but I liked it very much and the gundam designs are one of the best in the series. I really enjoyed your post and Im glad if I hear your reply.

    • I do think that Macross Plus if viewed as a stand-alone show, is perfect. In relation to other shows in the franchise, it is the most “adult” and darkly so. In terms of production values it is still very beautiful and as cel animation goes, it still has the most striking and beautiful dogfights in anime. In terms of CGI, the best would be Macross Zero.

      The thing about Plus, is that it is not very Macross — on purpose. The darkness of it all, the very adult themes, the weight of the personal issues are all very different from the rest of the franchise. Plus shows the viewers that the Macross franchise is versatile and rich, but I am loath to say that it is the best representative of it.

      If you haven’t completed Stardust Memory then you really, really should. I too love the designs here as evidenced by all the words I have to say about it in this post.

  22. Pingback: Moments of 2010: The Universal Century Joins the 21st Century By Celebrating With a 3-Way Prototype Mobile Suit Brawl (Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn 02) | We Remember Love

  23. Pingback: The Relevant Brilliance of Broken Blade (Finale) | We Remember Love

  24. Pingback: Countdown to the End of the World/Galaxy: ghostlightning’s 30 Favorite Anime of All Time (30-21) | We Remember Love

  25. Pingback: The White Wolf is a Fun Guy–Mobile Suit Gundam AGE 04 | We Remember Love

  26. Pingback: Forever Young | We Remember Love

  27. Pingback: The Start Of The Second Age: Mobile Suit Gundam AGE 16 | We Remember Love

  28. Pingback: The Greatest Time To Be a Gundam Fan | We Remember Love

  29. Pingback: The Impracticality of Ace Pilots Vs. The Alien Apocalypse: Muv Luv Alternative Total Eclipse Episode 03 | We Remember Love

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s